What is a feedback question exploring?
An interviewer may ask, “Tell me about feedback you received”, “How did you respond to criticism?” or “Describe a time feedback changed your approach.” The wording varies, but a strong response usually demonstrates that you can listen, examine evidence, choose a proportionate action and check whether it helped.
The Medical Schools Council’s statement on the values and attributes needed to study medicine includes reflection, communication and teamwork. The GMC’s Good medical practice, Domain 1 says medical professionals should respond constructively to reviews, reflect on feedback and use it to improve. Those professional duties apply to medical professionals rather than applicants, but they explain why thoughtful use of feedback matters in medical education.
Receiving feedback well does not mean accepting every comment immediately. It means taking it seriously enough to clarify what was observed, separate the useful evidence from your first emotional reaction and decide what to do next.
Universities choose their own questions and assessment criteria. The framework, questions and examples below are original Summit practice material, not recalled interview content or a universal marking scheme.
Use the HEAR framework
HEAR keeps the answer focused on learning rather than on a long description of the situation.
- Hear: state the feedback accurately. What did the person observe, and what was your first reaction?
- Explore: ask for an example, consider the impact and decide whether the comment identifies a pattern or a single event.
- Act: describe one or two specific changes. “I tried harder” is too vague; explain the behaviour you practised.
- Review: show how you checked the effect and what you still need to improve.
Keep the discomfort in the story
It is credible to say that feedback surprised or disappointed you. Briefly acknowledge the reaction, then show how you stopped it controlling your response. Claiming that criticism never affects you can sound rehearsed rather than reflective.
Worked example: making a presentation clearer
Practice question: Tell me about a time you received constructive feedback. What did you do with it?
Example answer: “After a group presentation, my teacher said that my slides were too dense and that I often repeated the text instead of helping the audience follow the main point. I was initially disappointed because I had spent a lot of time researching and thought the detail showed that I was well prepared.
“I asked her to show me one slide where the problem was clearest. When we compared it with a stronger slide from the presentation, I could see that mine contained several messages and gave the audience no clear priority. I also asked a teammate what they had noticed. They agreed that I tended to explain every line when I was nervous.
“For our next presentation, I limited each slide to one main message, moved supporting detail into my notes and rehearsed without reading from the screen. I then asked a friend to listen and tell me the single point they took from each section. If their answer differed from my intention, I simplified it again.
“In the next presentation, the teacher said that the structure was much clearer. She also noticed that I rushed the transitions between speakers, so the improvement was not complete. I learned that thorough preparation is only useful if it helps the audience understand, and that specific feedback gives me something testable to change. I now build in an audience check before presenting, and my next step is to rehearse handovers as carefully as the content.”
This fictional answer works because the applicant reports the feedback precisely, includes an honest first reaction, seeks evidence, changes observable behaviour and measures the result. It does not treat positive follow-up as proof that the skill is finished.
What if you disagree with the feedback?
Disagreement is not automatically defensiveness. Feedback may be vague, based on incomplete information or different expectations. A mature response is curious and proportionate:
- Clarify the observation: “Could you give me an example of when that happened?”
- Check the impact: ask what the behaviour made harder and for whom.
- Look for other evidence: has the same point appeared in another setting, or does the work itself support it?
- Explain your perspective calmly: add relevant context without trying to win an argument.
- Agree a useful next step: test a change, request another observation or seek guidance from an appropriate teacher or supervisor.
You do not need to say that every criticism was correct. You do need to show that you examined it fairly. If feedback involved safety, discrimination, bullying or another serious concern, an applicant should use the appropriate school, workplace or volunteering procedure rather than trying to resolve it alone.
How should you discuss giving feedback?
A follow-up may reverse the situation: “How would you give difficult feedback to a teammate?” Avoid presenting yourself as the person who simply tells others what they did wrong. Use observation, impact and invitation:
- Choose the right time and place: avoid public embarrassment and check that the person can talk.
- Describe behaviour, not character: “We started ten minutes late twice” is fairer than “You are unreliable”.
- Explain the impact: connect the observation to the task or the team.
- Invite their view: there may be context you do not know.
- Agree a practical change: make the next step clear and achievable.
For example: “Could we review how the meeting went? I noticed I answered several questions before you had finished explaining your idea, and that may have limited the discussion. How did it feel from your side? In the next meeting I could pause and summarise before adding my view.” This owns your observation and opens a conversation; it is not a script for every situation.
The GMC’s guidance on becoming a reflective practitioner describes giving constructive, honest feedback and being responsive to feedback as part of professional learning. Applicants can practise those behaviours in ordinary school, work, sport and volunteering contexts without claiming clinical experience.
Practise the likely follow-up questions
“Why did the feedback matter?”
Explain the effect on another person, the team or the quality of the task. “It helped me get a better mark” may be true, but it says less than explaining how your change made information easier to understand.
“What would you do if you received the same feedback again?”
Do not become defensive. Say you would examine why your first strategy had not transferred, ask for a fresh example and adjust the plan. Repeated feedback can reveal that a change worked in one context but not yet under pressure.
“How do you know you improved?”
Use evidence: another observation, a clearer outcome, a recording, peer feedback or a repeated task. Avoid relying only on “I felt more confident”.
“What feedback do you find hardest to hear?”
Name a type of feedback and explain why, then show the routine that helps you process it. The answer should reveal a strategy, not claim immunity from emotion.
“When would you not act on feedback?”
You might not follow a suggestion if evidence shows it would undermine the task, conflict with an agreed requirement or create a safety or ethical concern. Explain that you would clarify expectations and seek appropriate guidance rather than dismissing it privately.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Turning feedback into praise: “My only feedback was to keep doing what I was doing” avoids the question.
- Skipping the action: reflection without a behavioural change is incomplete.
- Saying you agreed instantly: this can hide the thinking process the interviewer wants to understand.
- Blaming the giver: you can question feedback without attacking the person who offered it.
- Claiming a dramatic transformation: one positive outcome rarely proves lasting change.
- Using a vague result: identify how you checked progress.
- Revealing confidential details: anonymise other people and avoid unnecessary personal information.
- Memorising the example word for word: prepare the evidence and reasoning, then speak naturally.
Build your own feedback example
Choose an example from school, paid work, volunteering, sport or another genuine responsibility. Write one sentence for each prompt:
- What were the exact words or observable point in the feedback?
- What was my first reaction, and how did I manage it?
- What example or evidence helped me understand the point?
- Who was affected by the behaviour?
- What single change did I make?
- How did I test or measure the effect?
- What remains difficult, and what will I try next?
If your notes contain only “I listened and improved”, choose a more specific example. If the story spends a minute describing the task before reaching the feedback, shorten the scene-setting.
A 20-minute practice session
- Minutes 1–4: list three occasions when someone suggested a change. Choose the one with the clearest action and evidence.
- Minutes 5–8: make four HEAR notes. Keep each to one sentence.
- Minutes 9–11: answer the main question aloud in 90 seconds.
- Minutes 12–14: ask a partner to challenge you: “How do you know the feedback was fair?” and “How do you know you improved?”
- Minutes 15–17: role-play a teammate saying, “You dominated that discussion.” Clarify the observation before defending yourself.
- Minutes 18–20: repeat the answer with a shorter situation, a more precise action and one honest next step.
Final self-check
Have I stated the feedback accurately? Shown my reaction without dwelling on it? Asked what the feedback meant? Changed an observable behaviour? Checked the result? Identified continuing development?
Official sources
These sources were checked on 1 November 2026:
- Medical Schools Council: Statement on the core values and attributes needed to study medicine
- GMC: Good medical practice, Domain 1 — Knowledge, skills and development
- GMC: Becoming a reflective practitioner
This guide is interview preparation, not clinical advice. Follow each medical school’s current applicant and interview instructions.