What is a data interpretation task asking you to do?
A table or graph can look intimidating when the subject is unfamiliar. Start with the information you have been given: what is measured, how the groups compare and which conclusions the evidence can support. You do not need to turn a short dataset into a diagnosis or a complete policy recommendation.
As checked on 3 November 2026, the University of Birmingham’s medicine interview guidance for 2027 entry lists data interpretation and debate among possible stations for Home applicants. It describes interpreting information, drawing appropriate conclusions and communicating accurately in accessible language, without requiring prior clinical knowledge for that task. This is one university’s published guidance, not a universal interview format. Follow the instructions for your own school, applicant category and entry year.
This guide provides an original Summit exercise. The dataset is entirely fictional: it is not NHS performance data, a recalled interview station or a university marking scheme.
Read the task before calculating
First identify the instruction. “Describe” asks what the data show. “Compare” requires differences and similarities. “Evaluate” asks you to judge what can be concluded and what limits that judgement. If you are asked for a calculation, state the calculation and units before discussing possible explanations.
- Identify the measure: are you looking at people, appointments, percentages, costs or time?
- Check the denominator: a count of missed appointments means little without knowing how many appointments were scheduled.
- Check the comparison: are the time periods, definitions and populations comparable?
- Describe the main pattern: choose one or two accurate observations rather than reading every number aloud.
- State the limit: explain what additional information would be needed to support a stronger claim.
If a graph is provided, read both axes, the units and the legend. Check whether the axis starts at zero, whether the scale is linear and whether the points represent equal time intervals. A striking visual gap does not remove the need to check the underlying numbers.
Original practice dataset: missed appointments
Two fictional clinics recorded scheduled and missed appointments during two equal-length periods. Clinic A introduced a reminder system between the periods; Clinic B did not. Assume that both used the same definition of a missed appointment and that all scheduled appointments were recorded. No other information about the clinics or patients is supplied.
| Clinic | Period | Scheduled | Missed |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | Before | 200 | 20 |
| A | After | 200 | 12 |
| B | Before | 400 | 24 |
| B | After | 400 | 20 |
Your task: calculate each missed-appointment rate, compare the changes and explain whether these figures establish that Clinic A’s reminder system caused an improvement. Try the calculations before reading the solution.
Worked calculations: counts, rates and changes
The missed-appointment rate is missed appointments ÷ scheduled appointments × 100.
- Clinic A before: 20 ÷ 200 × 100 = 10%.
- Clinic A after: 12 ÷ 200 × 100 = 6%.
- Clinic B before: 24 ÷ 400 × 100 = 6%.
- Clinic B after: 20 ÷ 400 × 100 = 5%.
Both clinics recorded a lower rate afterwards. Clinic A fell by 4 percentage points and Clinic B by 1 percentage point. Clinic A had the larger decrease, but Clinic B still had the lower rate in the second period. Those are different comparisons, and both are relevant.
The Office for National Statistics distinguishes percentage points from percentage change. Percentage points describe the difference between two percentages. Relative percentage change uses the original value as the denominator.
For Clinic A, the relative reduction is (10 − 6) ÷ 10 × 100 = 40%. For Clinic B, it is (6 − 5) ÷ 6 × 100 ≈ 16.7%. Saying Clinic A improved “by 4%” would be ambiguous and would not accurately state either calculation. Say “a fall of 4 percentage points, equivalent to a 40% relative reduction”.
Keep the unit attached to the number
Clinic A recorded eight fewer missed appointments, a four-percentage-point fall in the rate and a 40% relative reduction. These describe the same change in different ways. They are not interchangeable figures, and none tells us how many individual patients were involved.
A worked spoken answer
Illustrative response: “The table compares scheduled and missed appointments in two clinics before and after one clinic introduced reminders. I would compare rates because Clinic B scheduled twice as many appointments.
“Clinic A’s missed-appointment rate fell from 10% to 6%, a reduction of four percentage points. Clinic B’s fell from 6% to 5%, a reduction of one percentage point. So Clinic A had the larger improvement, although its final rate remained higher than Clinic B’s.
“The pattern is consistent with reminders possibly helping, but it does not establish that they caused the change. Both clinics improved, and we do not know whether their patients, appointment types or other arrangements were comparable. I would want to know what else changed, how rates varied over several earlier periods, and whether reminders reached the intended patients.
“I would describe these figures as a reason to investigate further, not proof that the system should be introduced everywhere. Any wider decision would also need evidence about cost, accessibility, patient experience and whether the improvement lasts.”
This answer names the denominator, distinguishes change from final performance and gives a bounded conclusion. It does not claim statistical significance, calculate a clinical benefit or blame people who missed appointments.
What does the dataset not tell you?
Listing every possible limitation can make an answer unfocused. Select the missing information that could actually change your conclusion:
- Other changes: did appointment availability, staffing or booking arrangements change at the same time?
- Baseline differences: did the clinics serve different populations or appointment types? Clinic A began with a higher missed-appointment rate.
- Variation over time: were these periods typical, or might a longer series show similar fluctuations without reminders?
- Reach and accessibility: were contact details accurate, and could people use or understand the reminder?
- Unit of analysis: were some appointments for the same person? Appointment counts are not necessarily counts of independent patients.
The change in Clinic A’s rate exceeded Clinic B’s change by three percentage points. That arithmetic is descriptive. Without a justified comparison design and further evidence, it is not automatically the effect caused by the reminder system.
A good limitation is connected to a next question. Instead of “The sample is biased”, say “I do not know how these clinics were selected or whether they are comparable, so I would check that before generalising”.
Explain the result without jargon
For someone unfamiliar with percentages, you could say: “In Clinic A, about ten out of every hundred scheduled appointments were missed before, compared with six out of every hundred afterwards. We cannot tell from this table alone why that changed.” That keeps the original denominator and the uncertainty visible.
Avoid turning “four fewer missed appointments per hundred scheduled” into “four patients benefited”. The table does not measure benefit, health outcomes or unique patients. Clear communication includes choosing what not to claim. Our communication guide explores how to check that an explanation is understood.
Follow-up questions to practise
Which clinic performed better?
Clarify the measure. Clinic B had the lower final missed-appointment rate; Clinic A had the larger reduction. Neither fact alone establishes better overall care.
Does a larger sample always mean a better study?
No. More observations do not by themselves correct a poor comparison, an unrepresentative sample or inaccurate measurement. Ask about how the data were collected as well as how much was collected.
What if you make an arithmetic mistake?
Correct it plainly: “I used the wrong denominator; I’ll recalculate using scheduled appointments.” Then update any conclusion affected by the error. Do not keep defending an answer after noticing the calculation is wrong.
Would you recommend the reminder system?
Give a proportionate response: these results justify further evaluation, not an unconditional recommendation. Specify the evidence you would seek rather than treating uncertainty as a reason to say nothing.
A 20-minute practice session
- Minutes 1–4: calculate the four rates without looking at the answers. Write the denominator and units each time.
- Minutes 5–7: explain the difference between counts, percentage points and relative percentage change aloud.
- Minutes 8–10: give a 90-second interpretation of the table. This is a practice timing, not a prediction of an interview station.
- Minutes 11–14: ask a partner to challenge one conclusion and request a jargon-free explanation.
- Minutes 15–17: try a new example: Group X has 3 events in 10 observations; Group Y has 30 events in 100. Both rates are 30%, despite different counts. What else would you need to compare the groups?
- Minutes 18–20: repeat your weakest explanation and check whether you now state the denominator and the limit clearly.
Reflect afterwards: Did I read the task before calculating? Did I confuse a percentage with a percentage point? Did I describe a possible explanation as a proven cause? Could my partner repeat the main result accurately?
Official sources and scope
Sources checked 3 November 2026:
- University of Birmingham: Medicine interviews, 2027-entry guidance
- Office for National Statistics: Percentages and percentage points
The fictional dataset, answer and practice exercise are Summit Interview Academy’s original teaching material. Neither source endorses Summit. This is interview preparation, not clinical advice or a university scoring rubric. Always follow your own interview invitation and current official instructions.
The £99 video bank and £250 personalised mock are separate purchases. The former supports independent preparation; the latter provides individual practice and feedback. Neither is required to apply to medicine or guarantees an offer.